The state is still touting it's secretive and expensive economic incentives program. (Via Flickr)

Florida is still touting its secretive and expensive economic incentives program. (Photo: Flickr)

By Ashley Lopez
Florida Center for Investigative Reporting

During a meeting before an economics panel in the state Legislature, Gov. Rick Scott’s commerce secretary, Gray Swoope, defended the state’s controversial economic incentive program. The program hands out millions of tax dollars in the hopes that the companies create jobs or keep their business in Florida.

However, to this day, the transparency of this program has been almost nonexistent. In short, officials have yet to prove that this program has even created jobs in the past several years.

The Orlando Sentinel reports that Swoope said, “Florida’s tax-incentives had created 103,000 jobs since 1995, at a cost to taxpayers of $335 million.”

However, the information supporting those claims is mostly not public.

According to the Sentinel:

With a PowerPoint displaying Scott’s “7 years = 700,000 jobs,” Swoope said the governor’s team was doing more with fewer dollars, and the governor was well on his way to meeting his campaign job-target.

“The story is more jobs, better wages, better return, and less money going out. It’s a strong story,” Swoope said.

For the last year, Scott’s jobs agency has struggled to provide proof Florida’s tax-incentives have created the promised jobs over the last two decades. His Department of Economic Opportunity is on its third executive director in less than two years.

This summer, Senate President Don Gaetz, R-Niceville, and Minority Leader Chris Smith, D-Fort Lauderdale, forced the agency to go out for bids to hire an outside auditor to review its incentive awards. The agency said Wednesday it was “very close” to finalizing a contract with a CPA. Lawmakers last year also pushed the agency to create an online portal to disclose contracts, and it debuted this summer — although a majority of the contracts awarded since 195 aren’t on it yet.

Last year, a movie company called Digital Domain, which is based in Port St. Lucie, filed for bankruptcy. This was after  Floridians had shelled out about $20 million in economic incentives to the company. Digital Domain laid off about 300 Florida employees and local governments were expected to lose an additional $110 million.

For years, the state has spent millions on these handouts to businesses in the state in the hopes this would generate job growth. During the Scott administration, these “incentives,” along with massive tax breaks, have been the bedrock of the state’s job creation plans.

According to earlier reporting from the Sentinel:

During his first 16 months in office, Scott has been cutting economic-development deals at a faster pace than his two predecessors, according to an Orlando Sentinel analysis of the contracts the Governor’s Office has signed.

The deals reflect the former CEO-turned-governor’s broader economic-development “stimulus” strategy: cheaper, smaller and sometimes higher-risk. And they show something else: Instead of bringing in new companies from out of state, a majority of Scott’s economic-development deals are going to companies already here.

The only light shed so far on this controversial program has been by accident. This is despite the fact that lawmakers promised to bring more transparency to the program.

Last year, state lawmakers promised progressives that there would be more transparency around the state’s economic incentives program. During this last legislations session, Florida Senate President Mike Haridopolos committed to including “a formal study reviewing the effectiveness of economy development incentives, tax credits, exemptions, and subsidies,” in the state’s economic incentives bill.

This followed a report that came out the year before from the Florida Center for Fiscal Policy and Economic Policy. The report (PDF) called on legislators to evaluate whether the many tax breaks and grants afforded to companies by the state are actually creating jobs. The public policy group argued that the state “provides huge benefits to selected companies each year, many of which receive little or no examination of their value to Florida’s economy.” At least $4 billion in annual breaks have been given to businesses in Florida in the past couple of years, the group reported.

Over time this veil has allowed lawmakers to make big claims about the effectiveness of the program — that is, without any publicly released data to defend those claims. This week, officials continued more of the same.



5 Responses

  1. boca raton summer camps for children

    Have the children drop by to pick up their lunch at the Mess Hall (kitchen or place
    where lunch boxes are placed). Vocabulary and grammar would center around what was necessary for reading and discussing the
    book. Vancouver Hockey Camps offers lessons and training that teaches kids and youth competitive hockey skills designed to improve overall
    individual and team playing ability. Fight your way out of the ambush and then take the
    crate back to Mayes. Well boot camps will not only help you only
    four days in case you are not familiar with concepts which are covered under PMBOK guide.
    Frankly, there’s not much of a rush to do this at a low level,
    so you can just wait until you have the necessary points (you need to
    be able to clear out Nelson in the next mission, so you may have to wait a bit anyway).
    The problem of teen boot camp aggression is going to be tackled
    in a systematic manner, in a good juvenile camp. It can also be taken up later as a part of regular sport curriculum to participate in various competitions.

    The most basic instruction a recruit receives is related to guarding military equipment.
    The teacher can pass out the boxes and eat lunch around the campfire,
    outdoors, in the cabins or tents.

    my web-site – boca raton summer camps for children

  2. south beach marketing and promotion

    It is also important to educate and train employees and help them learn the ill consequences of information flow.
    They are tasked with bringing order to your life in particular
    and society in general. Learn the new marketing trends related to your line of business.
    So now, for a month, we’re up to $1150-$10,350 in work hours that has
    been spent on social networking. Before developing a specific social
    media marketing strategy, figure out which social networking site you want to
    use. Social engineering can be performed through pretexting, phishing,
    baiting and mining social networks. Blog articles need not be extremely long, a
    few sentences is enough of an introduction just to post some photos, though occasional multi-paragraph posts help create a sense
    of depth. You can find a numerous affiliate marketer networks on the internet which make it a possibility to offer lots of products and
    solutions. It’s important to pick an agency with experience
    and an understanding of the process so it can promote successful campaigns and prune the lame ducks, thus
    getting the most out of ad spend. But now, with the prevalence of
    social media accounts, caretakers must now tackle the hurdle that is their loved one’s online presence.

    Here is my homepage: south beach marketing and promotion

  3. hcg drops

    Howdy! This is my 1st comment here so I just wanted
    to give a quick shout out and say I genuinely enjoy reading your blog posts.
    Can you recommend any other blogs/websites/forums that go over the same topics?
    Many thanks!

  4. spray tan kitchener

    But the catch here is that you need to find a good hair transplant surgeon to do the job, if you really want good results.
    If you are not a person who enjoys going to the beach for tanning,
    then such products may just be what you need. It has been approved by
    the National Sanitation department.

    Also visit my webpage: spray tan kitchener


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.